Category Archives: Phantom Band, The

2015 Live

2015-11-20 20.36.17
Live Band of the Year – Mercury Rev

Unusual to make this award on the basis of just 1 gig but haven’t quite knowing what to expect from Mercury Rev in 2015 I was delighted to find that everything I loved about them as a live band was still present and correct including the psychedelic live freak-outs.

Coming close were Idlewild, Julian Cope and Book Group.

A Baker’s Dozen of the Best gigs

1. Mercury Rev / Nicole Atkins – The Art School, Glasgow – Friday 20th November

2. West End Festival All Dayer – featuring The Phantom Band, Bill Wells & Aidan Moffat, We Were Promised Jetpacks, RM Hubbert, Tuff Love, De Rosa and ULTRAS – Oran Mor, Glasgow – Sunday 21st June 2015

3. Book Group / digitalanalogue – Sneaky Pete’s, Edinburgh – Friday 5th June 2015

4. Spare Snare / Emma Pollock – D.C.A., Dundee – 5th September 2015

5. Wire / PINS – The Lemon Tree, Aberdeen – Sunday 26th April 2015

6. Julian Cope / Henry Raby – The Duchess, York – Sunday 2nd August 2015

7. Idlewild – Perth Concert Hall – Tuesday 24th November 2015

8. Ash / Hyena / The Bucky Rage – Liquid Room, Edinburgh – Tuesday 9th June 2015

9. Tuff Love / Bruising / A Hooker Without Jesus – Drouthy’s, Dundee – 28th May 2015

10. Kid Canaveral’s Xmas Baubles XI – featuring Kid Canaveral, Bossy Love, De Rosa, Prehistoric Friends, Kathryn Joseph, ULTRAS and the Pictish Trail19th December 2015

11. The Cathode Ray / A Modern Masquerade – ‘Infinite Variety’ LP Launch – The Voodoo Rooms, Edinburgh – Thursday 14th May 2015

12. Randolph’s Leap’s I Can’t Dance To This Music 3 – CCA, Glasgow – Saturday 21st March 2015

13. STOOR – Drouthy’s Dundee – 23rd December

Last only because it’s the only gig this year that’s not had its own dedicated post. But STOOR were a ferocious live prescence throughout 2015 and this show, a large part of which was based on songs drawn from Santa’s hat (and one that was neither drawn from the hat nor rehearsed!) was probably the best. Although the album launch ran it close.

A few of photos from the show to prove that I was there:


20151223_stoor1 20151223_stoor2 20151223_21084820151223_stoor3

Gig stats

Over the last 12 months I saw 33 different shows comprising 89 performances (in whole or in part). As predicted 12 months ago, that represents a drop even on 2014’s attendance although a combination of ill health and the Forth Road Bridge closure meant that I messed out on a few shows at the end of the year in Edinburgh.

In the course of the last 12 months I saw 70 different (musical) acts perform seeing the following acts more than once:

Book Group – 5
De Rosa, Idlewild, STOOR, Tuff Love* – 3
The Cathode Ray*, A Hooker Without Jesus, The Phantom Band, Prehistoric Friends, ULTRAS, Vladimir, We Were Promised Jetpacks – 2
Bills Wells & Aidan Moffat – 1.25

*includes Record Store Day performance

The 33 shows took place in 22 different venues, 6 of which I visited for the first time (for gigs at least).

Venues which I visited more than once:

Beat Generator, Dundee 4; Summerhall, Edinburgh – 3; Buskers, Dundee; Drouthy’s, Dundee; Pilrig St Pauls Hall, Edinburgh; The Green Room, Perth 2.

I went to shows in the following towns/cities:

Edinburgh, Dundee – 10; Glasgow – 4; Perth – 3; Aberdeen, Dunfermline, Newport-on-Tay, York – 1


Heaven Up Here – West End Festival


The Phantom Band

West End Festival All Dayer – featuring The Phantom Band, Bill Wells & Aidan Moffat, We Were Promised Jetpacks, RM Hubbert, Tuff Love, De Rosa and ULTRAS – Oran Mor, Glasgow – Sunday 21st June 2015

It’s been a hectic week so it’s taken me this long to get the chance to sit down and reflect on Sunday’s West End Festival Alldayer at the Oran Mor. And, boy, there’s plenty to reflect on.

This was the first chance I’d had to see the Auditorium at the Oran Mor and it’s an impressive setting for a show. Whereas the Venue in the basement is dark and claustrophobic, the Auditorium, effectively the top part of the former chart is grand and roomy.

One imponderable as a first timer was how easy it would be to move between the stages. As it turned out the level of sales made it quite possible to see what you wanted although the smaller Venue was pretty crammed by the time of Wells & Moffat (and correspondingly it subsequently took a while for the Auditorium to fill up for the Phantom Band).

Whilst it would be therefore possible to pretty much see at least a part of every act performing, our approach was more geared around seeing as much of the bands that we wanted to see as we could. So the likes of Stanley Odd and Remember Remember missed out on an MPT presence whilst the one serious clash of the days – the Phantom Band vs Wells & Moffat was resolved in favour of the Phantos.

So let’s start at the end and the Phantom Band’s quite astonishing headline set. Whereas at times some of the earlier acts struggled to fill the huge spaces of the Auditorium the Phantos managed this with no bother. Instead it rather felt more like the room was struggling to contain them.

Although the crowd was initially comparatively meagre due to the aforementioned clash (Rick thanking those present for being ‘up here’ rather than ‘down there’), there was a huge energy about the performance with the likes of ‘The Kingfisher’ sounding more than a little unhinged whilst ‘Sweatbox’ got a serious groove on.

In fact a lot of the performance was about the groove and to illustrate just how good they were there was some unlikely MPT dancing (although no alcohol had been consumed) and even a severely improbable Manic Pop Pogo during the closing ‘Throwing Bones’.

The best set I’ve ever seen them play – and that’s saying something.

The Phantom Band played:

1. Tender Castle 2. The Wind That Cried The World 3. Doom Patrol 4. Local Zero 5. Sweatbox 6. The Kingfisher   7. The Howling 8. Into The Corn 9. Clapshot 10. Women of Ghent 11. Throwing Bones


De Rosa

The Phantos weren’t the principal reason for finally getting to an event that I’d been tempted by in previous years. No, that was the second live performance by the reformed De Rosa albeit with a different line-up from the Baubles show at the end of 2013. Stripped back to the original trio the sound was bolstered by the addition of Gill Fleetwood on keyboards and backing vocals with the latter something which the band have lacked in the past.

It was a sombre set in a lot of respects and initially a little tentative. A downbeat ‘New Lanark’ opened the show whilst the set also featured the likes of ‘Pest’ and ‘Tinto’ and no obvious pop tunes.

But the performance was really energised with the electro double header of ‘In Code’ and ‘Nocturne’. That built everyone up perfectly for  the undoubted highlight of the show – a spine tingling ‘Spectres’ to close – real hairs standing on the back of the neck stuff.

It’s great to have them back.

De Rosa played:

1. New Lanark 2. The Mute 3. Tinto 4. The Engineer 5. In Code 6. Nocturne for an Absentee 7. Pest 8. Spectres


Tuff Love

It’s only been a couple of weeks since I last saw Tuff Love but if anything they’ve got better in the interim. The set was similar to the Dundee show and with most of the hits at the back end a real sense of momentum was built up. But sound-wise it was a step up even from that impressive show.

The most memorable thing about the show though was the Wall of Death when Suse convinced the audience to split into 2 halves then basically charge into each other. I suspect that the results were rather more genteel than at any metal concert but it was thoroughly entertaining.

Similarly R.M. Hubbert’s performance was notable for more than the music. In this case rather than forcing the audience into a kamikaze maneouvre what sticks out was the combative way in which Hubby took on the folk chatting through his songs. Berating them for their rudeness was appreciated by the vast majority of the folk in the room even if they were somewhat terrified that they might inadvertently interrupt the maestro.

The music, of course, was pretty great too with the highlight being the first time we’ve seen Aidan Moffat join Hubby on stage for the closing ‘Car Song’.


We Were Promised Jetpacks

Fresh from a tour of the continent, We Were Promised Jetpacks set their stall out rather differently from normal with a ‘stripped back’ performance. In practice this meant not just less noise but also less velocity with a remarkably controlled performance.

They’ve previously demonstrated that this approach can work on record (on the ‘The Last Place You’ll Look’ E.P.) but nevertheless it’s still impressive how tunes like ‘It’s Thunder, It’s Lightning’ and ‘Short Bursts’ work in this format.

Most of the noise in the set was reserved for a terrific take on ‘Peaks and Troughs’ from the last album but, particularly with MPT energy levels starting to flag, the overall effect of the slower approach was less satisfying than a regular show. Whilst I do think the approach is worth persevering with, perhaps dropping slower versions of songs in amongst the adrenaline of a regular set would work better than as an exercise in its own right.

Opening act ULTRAS were the only discovery of the day. Based around Gav Prentice formerly of Over The Wall, ULTRAS retain OTW’s knack for a great tune but presented in a harder edged package.

Interestingly unlike many of their contemporaries they don’t shy away  from taking a political stand with their material. Slightly ironically the most overtly political (and somewhat metallic) tune  ‘The Path To Being Paid’ was probably the song I enjoyed the least. But my overall impressions of the set were very positive.

Other than the full sets described above we did manage to catch a chunk of start of the Wells and Moffat set in the Venue before the Phantom Band. This was the one clash that I wish could have been scheduled out but knowing we weren’t hanging around it was difficult to get into the gentler songs from the back of the floor although ‘Lock Up Your Lambs’ was stonking.

What we saw was also slightly marred by folk talking at the bar (where was Hubby when we needed him?) but it was still enough to make us regret that we couldn’t have seen more.

Sometimes these events don’t quite live up to the sum of their parts and turn into tests of endurance but it’s fair to say that Sunday was one of the very best. Roll on next year!




A fearful Auditorium trying to stay quiet for R.M. Hubbert


The not particularly terrifying other half of the Tuff Love Wall of Death!

Weird Like Popeye – The Phantom Band live


The Phantom Band – Buskers, Dundee – Sunday 8th February 2015

If there’s one band in the last 12 months I wish that I’d seen play more often it’s the Phantom Band.

‘Strange Friend’ has been one of my favourite albums of the last few years but, before Sunday evening, I’d actually only seen two shows which featured songs from that record.

It really doesn’t feel like it’s been enough – particularly as the three shows have all been different.

Aberdeen in March combined the hits with an almost complete run through of ‘Strange Friend’ – an almost perfect setlist. Unfortunately it was somewhat undermined by a sludgy sound mix which buried Andy Wake’s keyboards, so important on the album, almost to the point of inaudibility.

By contrast the sound in October at the Pleasance Sessions was fabulously rich, but at just over an hour, the show was a tad on the short side.

Sunday night in Dundee was different again. It was one of the better sounding evenings I’ve experienced in the Doghouse/Buskers building but, whilst the core SF songs from October were retained, the set was lent a significantly different feel as the majority of new LP ‘Fears Trending’ was also played.

The immediacy of the ‘Stange Friend’ material  was matched by a storming ‘Throwing Bones’ to close the set. But otherwise the back catalogue took its cue from  the darker material on ‘Fears Trending’.


Photo by MPK2

A monolithic ‘Burial Sounds’ was one of the few choices from the debut and it fit perfectly alongside highlights from the new record including the psychedelic ska of ‘The Kingfisher’.

Prominently featured in the set were the philthy electro grooves on the likes of a magnificent ‘Denise Hopper’, regular live stand-out ‘Women of Ghent’ and ‘Into The Corn’ – the only choice from “difficult” second album ‘The Wants’.

As ever the songs, both old and new, remain constantly evolving in the live environment. Oldest song (and encore) ‘Crocodile’ has gained a false crescendo whilst much newer kid on the block ‘Sweatbox’ now boasts a synth intro (which confused the hell out of MPK2!)

Once upon a time, the Phantom Band could be a bit hit or miss live. That can’t be said these days and Sunday was ample evidence that the Phantos have developed into an unmissable live act.



1. Tender Castle  2. The Wind That Cried The World  3. Doom Patrol  4. Local Zero 5. Burial Sounds  6. Sweatbox  7. The Kingfisher  8. Into The Corn  9. Clapshot  10. Denise Hopper 11. Women of Ghent  12. Throwing Bones


13. Crocodile

2014 LPs – The Top Ten (plus Reissues/MPK2)


Somewhat belatedly, entirely due to circumstances outwith my control, here’s MPT’s favourite 10 albums of 2014 …

  1. The Phantom Band – Strange Friend


‘Strange Friend’ was a classic example of not knowing what you’re wanting until you get it. After a couple of plays I did think it was going to be a disappointment. After 4 or 5 it was odds on for album of the year. In some ways it eschews what I think I love about the Phantos but ends up sounding more like them than ever. Without doubt their best and most consistent record – so far. [Review]

  1. The Everlasting Yeah – Anima Rising


‘Anima Rising’ would have made a worthy sixth That Petrol Emotion record in that it has strong connections with the band’s past. But it definitely also managed to break new ground with a looser, funkier aesthetic at play. Spread the word! [Review]

  1. James King & The Lonewolves – Lost Songs of the Confederacy


Probably the rock’n’roll miracle of the year. The fact that ‘Lost Songs …’ exists would be enough in itself but that it lives up to the legend is quite astonishing. Our memories were not playing tricks – the Lonewolves had a trunk full of classic songs and many of them are on here. [Review]

  1. Split Single – Fragmented World


In many ways ‘Fragmented World’ is more unassuming than Jason Narducy’s past albums with Verbow yet without question it’s a far more consistent record. Taking a lot of its cues from a Sixties/psychedelic vibe it’s chock full of insistent hooks. [Review]

  1. Bob Mould – Beauty & Ruin


One thing that Bob has never done in his solo career is sound quite as much like H***** D*as he does here – and that return to past glories has done his profile no harm at all. Contrary to my initial impressions, B&R is, in fact, definitely stronger than ‘Silver Age’ and his best record in years. [Review]

  1. We Were Promised Jetpacks – Unravelling


‘Unravelling’ is another fascinating segment of WWPJ’s musical journey in which they all but leave the staccato rock of the debut behind. More expansive and somewhat less hurried it’s their third fine LP in an already impressive career. [Review]

  1. Malcolm Middleton/David Shrigley – Music & Words


I meant to review this but ran out of time. Foul mouthed, scatological yet utterly brilliant Middleton’s music ensures that this isn’t just a novelty record and bears repeated plays even if the likes of ‘Story Time’ won’t have quite the same WTF? impact as on the first play.

  1. Mogwai – Rave Tapes


With their status as Scottish indie royalty long secured, Mogwai proved they could do little wrong with another excellent record. It’s so good in fact that they were able to make a cracking E.P. out of tunes that didn’t make the main record.

  1. Deathcats – All Hail Deathcats!


Deathcats finally captured the essence of their live show on record with impressive results. Officially on hiatus at the moment, quite what the future holds for the band remains to be seen. But ‘All Hail’ makes me hope that there’s much more to come.

  1. King Post Kitsch – Sheep on a Beach


The ‘sleeper’ hit of 2014 for me. More angular than 2011’s debut ‘The Party’s Over’ SOAB is nevertheless just as rewarding. Probably the criminally Scottish released LP of 2014.

Reissues of the Year


  1. The Chills – BBC Sessions
  2. Bob Mould – Workbook 25
  3. Various Artists – C86
  4. Pixies – Doolittle 25
  5. The Wedding Present – The Hit Parade

And finally a MPT innovation …

MPK2’s Favourite Albums of the Year

  1. The Phantom Band – Strange Friend
  2. Withered Hand – New Gods
  3. Randolph’s Leap – Clumsy Knot
  4. Broken Records – Weights and Pulleys
  5. Malcolm Middleton/David Shrigley – Music & Words

At the moment, MPK2’s list is a subset of the main MPT list but I’m sure before long he’ll be off discovering new stuff all on his own.


Are You All Sitting Comfortably? Jesus … – The Phantom Band live


Phantom Band live outings have been rare since the release of ‘Strange Friend’  so the Skinny curated Pleasance Sessions appearance on Saturday night definitely fell into the ‘do not miss’ category.

It turned out to be quite a different experience from last time I saw the band in Aberdeen in June.

The biggest and most crucial difference was that the sound was excellent. Unlike in Aberdeen there was a real clarity which meant that the keyboards (AWOL that night) were present and correct.

Whilst the main theatre at the Pleasance has an old music hall charm, its biggest drawback is that it’s all seated.That was a problem because it’s pretty much impossible to fully enjoy the Phantoms whilst sitting down.

It was also, at just over an hour, a comparatively short set so the number of old favourites was cut back slightly whilst, disappointingly, half the new album was also jettisoned.

If the ‘Strange Friend’ material sounded just as good as the old classics, the standout for me was still a wonderful, euphoric version of ‘Throwing Bones’. Meanwhile the live evolution of ‘Crocodile’ continued with a version which seemed to be focusing on the groove in the song.


A couple of weeks ago, I was clear that this year’s live band of the year nomination was settled. After Saturday, I’m not sure I haven’t, maybe, jumped the gun on that.

A further chance to change my mind will take place on Thursday 11th December at Non-Zeros in Dundee.

The Phantom Band played:

1. The Wind That Cried The World  2. Doom Patrol  3. Sweatbox  4. Into The Corn  5. Clapshot  6. Throwing Bones  7. Women of Ghent  8. Crocodile

9. The Howling


Birdhead had opened the show with an excellent half hour set. It was the cleanest sounding set I’ve seen them play and, like the headliners, it sounded fantastic.

There didn’t seem to be a large number of folk in the theatre when they started but the crowd grew steadily throughout the set. And, if you’re out to make a good impression then the likes of ‘Tourist’, ‘Time Lag Accumulator’ and ‘Dronebone’, are a good way to do it. Such that by the end of their set Birdhead had a sizeable and appreciative audience.


All kudos to Remember Remember for carrying a lot of their melodies on a xylophone but my overriding impression of them was that they were … nice. Serious but nice and that’s not really enough for MPT.

Perhaps the slot did them little favours, placed between two such exciting live bands, but then again I suppose that I can’t love everyone and it seems that Remember Remember have slipped through the cracks.

Photos of all three acts can be found here.


The Winds That Sing – The Phantom Band LP review

Phantom Band 18th March

As much as I love the Phantom Band their two LPs to date haven’t quite delivered everything that I’d hoped for.

Debut ‘Checkmate Savage’ certainly has some of their very best tunes but it’s also a little uneven at times. Sophomore LP ‘The Wants’ is a more consistent record but the second side of that record perhaps doesn’t quite live up to the promise of the first half .

It gives me great pleasure therefore to be able to report that third LP ‘Strange Friend’ is the one where it all comes together.

In a way, rather strangely, ‘SF’ is something of an understated record. The odd flourish aside (for example the crashing guitars midway through ‘Doom Patrol’) it’s rarely attention grabbing. Indeed initially I wondered if it really lived up to the rave reviews it was receiving.

Often the easiest way into a record for me is through a handful of stand-out tracks which draw you in to the rest of the record. But ‘Strange Friend’ doesn’t offer that option – there are no stand-out tracks. More often than not that means that an album’s just not up to scratch. But not in this case because ‘Strange Friend’ is that rare record on which pretty much everything is as great as everything else.

For that reason I think it’s a record that you need to invest a little time in initially. But, boy, that pays rich rewards.

Because once you’ve scratched the surface not only do the differences between the songs get drawn out but the strength (and durability) of the melodies become clear. These are songs that not only bear, but insist on, repeated listens.

‘The Wind That Cried The World’ with its soaring, wordless chorus is probably the obvious single choice thanks its clarity of purpose. But there’s nothing quite like it elsewhere on the album.

But then that can be said too of the insistent electro dance stylings of ‘Women of  Ghent’ or the rhythmic clatter of ‘Galagapos’ or the lively lead guitar on ‘Sweatbox’ or … Well, you get my point.

The slower tracks deserve a mention too. ‘No Shoes Blues’ is lovely building from a downbeat intro before , whilst ‘(Invisible) Friends’ is every bit as good.

The largely acoustic ‘Atacama’ does stand a little apart from the rest of the record. But even if it sounds almost more like something from the Rick Redbeard solo album ultimately it belongs to an established Phantoms tradition of stripped back tunes such as ‘Island’ and ‘Come Away In The Dark’.

More than any Phantoms album to date, the keyboards are critical to the songs. There’s an 80s feel to some of these sounds which recall early 80s Simple Minds on he likes of ‘Sweatbox’ and, most notably, on the melody which accounts for half of the chorus on ‘Doom Patrol’.

There’s plenty of other reasons to love this record. ‘Strange Friend’ probably features Rick’s best vocal performances for the band with each and every one pitched perfectly for the songs and it’s those performances which invest the record with its emotional resonance. But there’s also the subtle little touches throughout, such as the brass towards the end of  ‘No Shoe Blues’ or the Prince-esque solo towards the end of ‘Sweatbox’ ,which confirm the band’s reputation for invention.

But perhaps what says it best for me is that it’s the first album in ages that’s been on repeat – again and again – even when there’s other excellent new stuff to be heard.

To the point then – ‘Strange Friend’ is a record that will keep rewarding you with every play and, even at this relatively early stage, I’m certain that anything that beats it for album of the year is going to have to be very special indeed.

‘Strange Friend’ is available from all good record shops or online from Chemikal Underground.


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 768 other followers